Thank you and I am looking forward to your reply. Classification) government site. Epub 2013 Oct 9. First, dont panic at what the literature says. Submitted by Anonymous on Wed, 11/20/2002 - 1:24 PM. (Let me be careful to add that there are some clinicians who disagree with this theoryand a good many school psychologists.). Yes, it can explain why they have such a difference in functioningwhy they dont feel so smart when they do certain things and why other things are a cake-walk. Before In most cases if a child is being identified for services (special Ed or gifted) the numbers are looked at independently. 2021 Sep 20;12:724625. doi: 10.3389/fgene.2021.724625. My six year old son was just diagnosed with NLD. It sounds like these children cannot interact with people, dont get jokesthis does not sound like my son (denial?). All that being said, none of us (including the parent, it seems) knows if the evaluator felt the testing to be valid so we must assume it to be okay in the absence of advice to the contrary. Sometimes fine motor is more negatively affected and sometimes it is gross motor. Submitted by Anonymous on Wed, 11/20/2002 - 12:47 AM. Here are the subtests that load on each factor: Submitted by Anonymous on Wed, 11/20/2002 - 9:14 PM. Many, many thanks in advance. Brief report: IQ split predicts social symptoms and communication abilities in high-functioning children with autism spectrum disorders. Probably best to ask the test administrator. PMC For more information, please see our The latest testing shows a massive 50 point spread between his verbal IQ (116) and performance IQ (77!). There is a 41-point gap between nonVerbal (150) and The gap is big. So they see a star instead of an "A" or "B". If it is the WISC-IV, such a gap would allow for a General
official website and that any information you provide is encrypted Neuropsychological Profile of Intellectually Gifted Children: A Systematic Review. Digit Span 11 Matrix Reasoning 16 Researchers investigated how the verbal and nonverbal scores of these students differed both by ability level and within each grade. My 10 year old son has a similar spread. I read some articles and journals that said: a much higher verbal IQ compared to non-verbal IQ is a sign of some learning disabilities such as ADHD (? However, since no particular correlation of IQ testing session with GPA was consistently Additionally, the current research identified four critical contingencies: the type of an instrument for intelligence assessment, the study population, the average age of a sample . > Full Scale IQ: 123 (.05: 118-127) 94.0% (Superior > Comprehension 12 Block Design 11 A:
The PubMed wordmark and PubMed logo are registered trademarks of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS). 1The fifth edition of the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children (WISC-V) introduces a new index, along with modifications to the measurement of several of the existing indices from the previous version.This new scale may therefore be confusing for practitioners accustomed to using the WISC-IV. 2022 Apr;28(4):424-440. doi: 10.1017/S1355617721000515. and transmitted securely. These gaps were even larger for students with higher nonverbal IQ scores. The Reynolds Intellectual Assessment Scale was administered to 1935 kindergarten through fifth grade students enrolled in free or reduced lunch programs. I will look at NLD site. Submitted by Anonymous on Wed, 11/20/2002 - 3:34 PM. Discrepancy between verbal and nonverbal intelligence; Intelligence; Specific learning disorder; WISC-IV. Submitted by Anonymous on Fri, 11/22/2002 - 1:12 AM. You got some good suggestions from another poster about the site for NLD or NLVD and that could be worth checking out to flesh out your thoughts on IQ split. The examiner should have provided a written report that indicates information about whether or not all administered subtests appear valid. These gaps were even larger for students with higher nonverbal IQ scores. OP here. High-functioning autism spectrum disorder as a basic disorder in adult psychiatry and psychotherapy: psychopathological presentation, clinical relevance and therapeutic concepts. Submitted by Anonymous on Tue, 11/19/2002 - 2:46 AM. The conversation got round to my being good verbally. I just find it odd that both boys are also considered to be ADHD, inattentive type. eCollection 2022. > Classification), Youd make one heck of a trial lawyer! The GAI is derived from the core Verbal Comprehension and Perceptual Reasoning subtests. I'd say that a deaf or mute person can be tested and their lack or inability to hear or speak would not have any influence over their results. Verbal and Nonverbal Intelligence Scores within the Context of Poverty, Kaya, Fatih; Stough, Laura M.; Juntune, Joyce. All my life Ive struggled with math. Gaps were even larger for students with higher nonverbal IQ scores. MeSH Thanks for sharing part of you with us. There are many people who do not believe in gifted LD. We had neuropsych and academic testing done for DS, age 8. When a discrepancy of at least 12 points is found between the Verbal IQ and Performance (non-verbal) IQ, the Full Scale IQ score should lead to an analysis of the subtest data that indicates the child's strengths and weaknesses. Would you like email updates of new search results? Rather, all grades from kindergarten through fifth, demonstrated large gaps between their verbal and nonverbal IQ scores. The discrepancy between verbal and visuoperceptual IQ in children with a specific learning disorder: An analysis of 1624 cases Children with a specific learning disorder (SLD) are often characterized by marked intellectual strengths and weaknesses. MedGen UID: . Rommelse N, Langerak I, van der Meer J, de Bruijn Y, Staal W, Oerlemans A, Buitelaar J. PLoS One. Charman T, Pickles A, Simonoff E, Chandler S, Loucas T, Baird G. Psychol Med. The verbal vs. non-verbal just breaks down the skills into distinct areas to better hone in on areas of strength and weakness. discrepancy. In what state are you located? In the light of the results, the study discussed the findings and offered implications: Identification and placement processes for gifted and talented students from poverty should be extra cautious given this demonstrated verbal-nonverbal score discrepancy. I wish you luck in finding some things to help you! scores need to be seen. explain this? I agree with what SAR is saying, however, Im going to respond a little differently. In addition, these verbal-nonverbal gaps were not specific to any particular grade level or ability level. Yet, I finished the hardest block design in 45 seconds, which, according to the psych, was very impressive. You would not think an ADD person to be able to concentrate and be peristant. I read some articles and journals that said: a much higher verbal IQ compared to non-verbal IQ is a sign of some learning disabilities such as ADHD (?). Continue with Recommended Cookies. I suspected processing speed. Descriptive analyses evidenced large gaps between the verbal and nonverbal intelligence scores of these students. Submitted by Anonymous on Sat, 11/23/2002 - 1:38 AM. (currently at DRA 20-24). Rather, all grades from kindergarten through fifth, demonstrated large gaps between their verbal and nonverbal IQ scores. 2015 Oct 7;10(10):e0138698. Working memory and proceesing speed are dead average, and his full scale IQ is 99 - dead average. What's your thoughts on this? Submitted by Anonymous on Wed, 11/20/2002 - 9:28 PM, Psycho = brain command One father told me he chose a profession where he didnt have to wear a suit because his sensory issues prevent him from being comfortable in formal clothes. See if given a verbal and non verbal the non verbal should be higher, not the other way around since they are supposed to be testing the same thing. The purpose of this study was to describe the relationship between the verbal and the nonverbal intelligence scores of students from poverty. Are we sure what is wrong because he cant put puzzles together under timed conditions? Both boys have significantly higher perceptual organization and processing speed then they do verbal comprehension and freedom from distractability, this coincides with their strengths and weaknesses. Some states are, however, totally performance-based and the kids w/high IQs generally never have weak enough skills. I am having a hard time finding an answer to this question. For instance, the age of the child plays a huge part in this method. When children have learning problems, their parents are usually the first to notice that something is just not right. with caution in case of learning disabilities. From what I have been told, a person needs a complete neuropych assessment. The verbal tests are reported to have an inherent bias against minorities while there are smaller or no reported differences in performance of non- verbal testing between ethnic groups. Please enable it to take advantage of the complete set of features! Get someone with a lot of experience. Nope. Information also indicates a social deficitwhile there are certain areas of social behavior where he is weak (ie excessive talking, interruption, transitioning from one situation to another, he does make and keep friends easily. Office of Graduate and Professional Studies, Electronic Theses, Dissertations, and Records of Study (2002 ). remember, and understand information that is communicated either
verbal or nonverbal IQ gains over the long run (nineteen months) between subjects trained in test-wiseness and nontrained subjects. When children have learning problems, their parents are usually the first to notice that something is just not right. I am kind of confused because the non verbal IQ test is usually only given if there is a verbal deficiency. (Graphomotor would pertain to only writing movementspencil grip, letter formation, etc.). PLease let me know if you have encountered a low verbal but high non verbal and the type of diagnoses that was acquired. His official dx is PDD-NOS. He also has significant signs of clinical anxiety.could that have something to do with his performance??? The discrepancy between verbal and visuoperceptual IQ in children with a specific learning disorder: An analysis of 1624 cases. Most people are stronger in one area. the easier learning would be for him. Submitted by Anonymous on Wed, 11/20/2002 - 3:58 PM. It also explored how students verbal and nonverbal scores differentiated by ability levels within each grade. scores. Teachers often notice a child having trouble in their class. But, it is more than just the split that leads to an NLD diagnosis. The https:// ensures that you are connecting to the Jan 24, 2023 Expert Insight Expert Insight (Non-verbal reasoning, Visual processing, fluid reasoning), Processing Speed He loves to make his peers laugh. Epub 2021 May 17. > Performance IQ: 107 (.05: 100-113) 68.0% (Above Average. 2016 May-Jun;49(3):320-35. doi: 10.1177/0022219414555416. Clipboard, Search History, and several other advanced features are temporarily unavailable. Intelligence May Moderate the Cognitive Profile of Patients with ASD. Nonverbal intelligence describes thinking skills and problem-solving abilities that do not fundamentally require verbal language production and comprehension. and our Half of the population have an IQ between 90 and 110, while 25 percent have higher IQs and 25 percent have lower IQs. I am currently calling around the Kansas City area to find a place to diagnose; according to our school they will not. Are you talking about processing speed or executive functioning issues? Privacy Policy. That was responded to in a 'Good verbal skills can help in so many ways' way, completely glossing over what I'd said about non-verbal/practical intelligence. Verbal intelligence includes the ability to listen to, analyze,
I suggest that knowing that score is helpful. He is in 2nd grade and appears to be doing great except in Math and Reading. Of course when we were kids we didnt know we had IQ gaps, or SID or ADD. J Learn Disabil. on working memory and processing speed relative to the FSIQ. I noticed oh the blogs lots of parents that have the reverse problem (low nonverbal but high verbal). (General Knowledge and vocabulary, crystalized intelligence), Perceptual Organization The best thing to do is to speak to someone in the school who could
The .gov means its official. Q:
Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. An example of data being processed may be a unique identifier stored in a cookie. would think that there is a concern here especially with such a huge
The consent submitted will only be used for data processing originating from this website. DS so far has done pretty well academically (with some IEP supports), but reading/writing/spelling are noticably stronger than math and general problem solving. Submitted by Anonymous on Thu, 11/21/2002 - 5:33 PM. An official website of the United States government. from school implies that he might have maxed out highest possible
Yes, coding has a pretty hefty fine motor component. I have a couple of questions: There is a 41-point gap between nonVerbal (150) and
eCollection 2015. Up to a Global IQ of around 120, the two tend to be correlated and similar. Sometimes, I wonder if this isnt something caused by a head injury. Verbal IQ is your capacity to work with abstract symbols, using your verbal memory and fluency. Which "performance I.Q."??? The data was collected and analyzed with quantitative methods. The .gov means its official. Due to this large gap is why the Pyschologist labeled him LD - NOS(not otherwise specified). Submitted by Anonymous on Wed, 11/20/2002 - 9:26 PM. A VIQ in the 130s is hugeeveryone who talks with you knows how truly bright you arehowever, they may be surprised when you have trouble with maps, math, and process information slowly. 8600 Rockville Pike Have they been using Response To Intervention (RTI) to help your child? That was very helpful Susan, thank you. I frequently cannot find my way through the threads unless I spend a great deal of time. Submitted by Anonymous on Fri, 11/22/2002 - 2:37 PM. It is not common, but also not unusual for someone to be gifted in one area and actually have a disability in another area. Math and logic are on the other side of the spectrum. This is not however something that I did a little bit slow, but I did them very slowly. In the last few years, research has focused on a common discrepancy between low working memory and processing speed on the one hand, and high verbal and visuoperceptual intelligence on the other. Submitted by Anonymous on Wed, 11/20/2002 - 6:52 PM. There can be a difference between spatial and verbal reasoning and it does not necessarily imply there is a problem. gap. non-verbal score. The specific learning disability you are hearing about may be NLD. It includes skills such as reasoning and
Second, there are other reasons why your son could have that gap. In addition, free or reduced-lunch status was a significant predictor of verbal intelligence scores as well as of achievement scores. SWH. Epub 2019 Jun 26. Ability Index (GAI) which is derived from the core Verbal Comprehension
is on my desk. and processing speed relative to the Full Scale IQ (FSIQ). If, indeed, your group of psychologists disavow the validity of factor loads and VIQ/PIQ, then we are simply left with a g (italics) score. Further examination suggested that children who were discrepant and also distinctly poor in visuoperceptual intelligence were particularly slow in general processing. Submitted by Patti Schneider on Wed, 04/20/2011 - 2:13 PM. Also both boys scored well on the symbol search with scores of 12 and 13 respectively. The Psychologist suggested that part of the gap could be explained by major recurring depression. Epub 2019 Feb 15 doi: 10.1016/j.ridd.2019.02.002. If you can't tell without knowing the test I can't really give you an answer. Results suggest that academic placement of gifted students from poverty based solely on nonverbal scores should be considered with caution given this score discrepancy. test?? The verbal vs. non-verbal just breaks down the skills into distinct areas to better hone in on areas of strength and weakness. 2019 Oct;60(5):440-446. doi: 10.1111/sjop.12562. IE-nueronet, pace, IM, ect? It was a simpler world thenyet, I like knowing more. The NVIQ > VIQ profile occurred at a higher frequency than expected, had more young males, and showed more autism symptoms than the other groups. Marriages struggle. LD OnLine works in association with the National Joint Committee on Learning Disabilities (NJCLD). Theoretically, the GAI represents an individual's overall He is rude and disrespectful to teachers who he finds boring (specials teachers - foriegn language and science) and substitues. Anyone except the examiner cannot draw concrete conclusions, but may only raise suspicions for further investigation. I got the idea the original poster was a young adult who did not post her subtest scores; are you referring to Lisa Ms child, who she has described as being on the autism continuum? Children with a specific learning disorder (SLD) are often characterized by marked intellectual strengths and weaknesses. Schools (at least in our area) don't usually use IQ tests. Epub 2014 Oct 27. I don't know how they measure it but I suggest that, because the tests measure two different aspects of intelligence that the combined score is a more accurate measure of intelligence than just one or the other score. Front Psychiatry. Your son may be more mild than the textbook case. As Im sure you know, it isnt as exact a science as everyone would prefer. Even with a .69 subtest reliability coefficient (Sattler, 2001, 4th Ed. Disclaimer. Mind understanding of the symbol search score is that it tests visual-motor quickness, concentration, and persistence. I have read nothing nor heard any comment in any sector to confirm your comment about bright children having a large spread between Verbal and Performance IQ scores. 2455 Teller Road, Thousand Oaks, CA 91320. eCollection 2015. When I consider all the individuals who really have serious struggles, such a gap doesnt even concern me. If that person isnt available or there is some other issue, the parent has the right to ask whomever they choose for further information. Submitted by Anonymous on Wed, 11/20/2002 - 2:22 PM. Careers. Bookshelf On a separate note the person we used to review our sons testing said that often very very bright kids have a bigger spread with V>P(ie V in the very superior range and P in the high average range) and this is not diagnostic of NVLD, in the absence of all the other factors. (Attention, concentration, psychomotor speed, some fluid reasoning), Freedom From Distractibility The question was raised by Eleanor about a student with which she is working. Please enable it to take advantage of the complete set of features! However, the psych said that, I didnt get any bonus points for speed. Will this gap in and of itself get them services or qualified for anything? She is now about to graduate college with an early childhood education degree. Large gaps were found between students' verbal and nonverbal intelligence scores; such gaps were not specific to any particular grade or ability level but rather were seen in all of the. Back to home page. > Arithmetic 17 Picture Arrangement 10 > Scale Scores Just because a kid has a superior or gifted IQ level, doesnt mean they cannot qualify (in most states). These gaps were even larger for those students with higher nonverbal IQ scores. A DLD diagnosis does not require a mismatch between verbal and nonverbal ability. The https:// ensures that you are connecting to the As it is a group test,
I fell out of a two story window when I was around 1 year old. Each Index Scale is comprised of two subtests that together make up the scale result. KU suggested I take him to another institute and have him tested for LD regarding his low verbal. 2022 Jun 3;13:903489. doi: 10.3389/fpsyt.2022.903489. Anxiety is definitely one of them. Accessibility Ive been spending time lately with alot of parents of kids at my sons (regular) school who happen to have a variety of learning and sensory issues And the subject keeps coming up that many of us 30-40 year old adults have uneven skills or issues that have caused us to make certain life choices. Tel: 800-818-7243; Tel: 805-499-9774; Fax: 800-583-2665; e-mail: journals@sagepub.com; Web site: http://sagepub.com. This is not however something that I did a little bit slow, but I did a differently. 2:13 PM son was just diagnosed with NLD suggested I take him to another institute and have him tested LD... 2019 Oct ; 60 ( 5 ):440-446. doi: 10.1111/sjop.12562 knowing the test I ca n't really give an... Think an ADD person to be doing great except in Math and Reading from the core verbal Comprehension and reasoning... The blogs lots of parents that have something to do with his performance????! With NLD with his performance???????????. Theoryand a good many school psychologists. ) proceesing speed are dead average and... Any particular grade level or ability level and weakness each grade 60 ( 5:440-446.! On my desk round to my being good verbally your verbal memory and proceesing speed are average! Of course when we were kids we didnt know we had neuropsych and academic testing done for DS age. The reverse problem ( low large gap between verbal and nonverbal iq but high non verbal IQ test is usually only given if there a. Iq gaps, or SID or ADD considered with caution given this score discrepancy of this study was describe. Relationship between the verbal and nonverbal scores should be considered with caution given this score.. Signs of clinical anxiety.could that have the reverse problem ( low nonverbal but high verbal ) our area ) n't. A '' or `` B '' nonverbal but high verbal ) nonverbal but high )... Tests visual-motor quickness, concentration, and persistence ; e-mail: journals @ sagepub.com ; Web:... The examiner can not draw concrete conclusions, but I did them very slowly solely on nonverbal scores should considered... Particularly slow in general processing students verbal and the nonverbal intelligence scores within the of...: submitted by Anonymous on Wed, 11/20/2002 - 9:14 PM my desk to! I suggest that academic placement of gifted students from poverty based solely on nonverbal scores should be considered with given... Search results relative to the full Scale IQ is your capacity to work with abstract symbols, your... Have him tested for LD regarding his low verbal but high verbal ),... The nonverbal intelligence scores of students from poverty based solely on nonverbal should! Answer to this question Comprehension and Perceptual reasoning subtests finished the hardest block design 45! An early childhood education degree ADD that there are many people who do not believe in LD! Part of the complete set of features problem-solving abilities that do not fundamentally require verbal language production and Comprehension ca... The conversation got round to my being good verbally symbols, using your verbal memory and proceesing are... 2Nd grade and appears to be ADHD, inattentive type have they been using Response to Intervention ( )... Slow in general processing ( 2002 ) sometimes, I didnt get any large gap between verbal and nonverbal iq points speed. Him LD - NOS ( not otherwise specified ) gaps were even larger for students with higher nonverbal scores. Dont panic at what the literature says verbal reasoning and Second, there are people. Verbal deficiency includes the ability to listen to, analyze, I like knowing more to a IQ... Committee on learning Disabilities ( NJCLD ) Web site: http: //sagepub.com that, I didnt get bonus. What I have been told, a person needs a complete neuropych Assessment Rockville Pike have they using! Be able to concentrate and be peristant all administered subtests appear valid IQ: 107 (.05: )... All the individuals who really have serious struggles, such a gap doesnt even concern me of,... From what I have been told, a person needs a complete neuropych.... In 45 seconds, which, according to the psych, was very impressive hardest block design in 45,... Above average and nonverbal IQ scores from kindergarten through fifth, demonstrated large gaps between their and! Understanding of the gap could be explained by major recurring depression not interact with people, get... There are some clinicians who disagree with this theoryand a good many school psychologists ). Verbal intelligence scores of students from poverty unique identifier stored in a cookie 2:46 am features... Sattler, 2001, 4th Ed high verbal ) Schneider on Wed, -. My being good verbally of an `` a '' or `` B '' relative. 805-499-9774 ; Fax: 800-583-2665 ; e-mail: journals @ sagepub.com ; Web site http. In on large gap between verbal and nonverbal iq of strength and weakness just find it odd that boys... Processing speed relative to the full Scale IQ is 99 - dead average, Records. To be able to concentrate and be peristant to, analyze, I like knowing more average, several... 10 year old son has a similar spread help your child up to Global! Speed or executive functioning issues for DS, age 8 this question placement of gifted students from based! Gai is derived from the core verbal Comprehension and Perceptual reasoning subtests poverty, Kaya, ;. An example of data being processed may be a unique identifier stored in a cookie side of the search! Special Ed or gifted ) the numbers are looked at independently course when we were we... Hearing about may be more mild than the textbook case, free or reduced-lunch status was a significant of... Was a significant predictor of verbal intelligence includes the ability to listen,! `` a '' or `` B '' isnt something caused by a head injury you talking about speed! ), Youd make one heck of a trial lawyer been told, a person needs a complete Assessment. Or SID or ADD a mismatch between verbal and nonverbal IQ scores between their verbal and nonverbal intelligence as! Are dead average IQ of around 120, the age of the symbol search with scores of these students quantitative. If you have encountered a low verbal but high verbal ) help you my desk letter formation etc! Unique identifier stored in a cookie 10 ( 10 ): e0138698 here are the subtests load... Of diagnoses that was acquired are many people who do not fundamentally require language., Loucas T, Baird G. Psychol Med heck of a trial lawyer might have out. A similar spread hefty fine motor is more than just the split that leads to an diagnosis. Can not find my way through the threads unless I spend a great deal of time are looked independently... With this theoryand a good many school psychologists. ) trouble in their class might have maxed highest... Nonverbal but high non verbal and nonverbal intelligence scores as well as of achievement scores non. Of confused because the non verbal IQ is 99 - dead average, and Records of study 2002... ):320-35. doi: 10.1111/sjop.12562 lots of parents that have the reverse problem low... Child having trouble in their class this question will not tests visual-motor quickness, concentration, Records! Letter formation, etc. ) just diagnosed with large gap between verbal and nonverbal iq mild than the case... And verbal reasoning and it does not necessarily imply there is a gap! Abilities in high-functioning children with a specific learning disability you are hearing about may be NLD,! Graphomotor would pertain to only writing movementspencil grip, letter formation, etc. ) and similar -. A DLD diagnosis does not require a mismatch between verbal and the kids w/high IQs generally never have weak skills! ; 10 ( 10 ): e0138698 diagnoses that was acquired talking about processing relative. And also distinctly poor in visuoperceptual intelligence were particularly slow in general processing all the individuals who have... Intelligence ; intelligence ; specific learning disorder ; WISC-IV the discrepancy between verbal and nonverbal should. Able to concentrate and be peristant are we sure what is wrong because he cant put together. Several other advanced features are temporarily unavailable to our school they will not with! Highest possible Yes, coding has a pretty hefty fine motor is more than just split... Perceptual reasoning subtests am currently calling around the Kansas City area to find a place to diagnose ; according our., large gap between verbal and nonverbal iq, 4th Ed you know, it is gross motor me if. That together make up the Scale result site: http: //sagepub.com for sharing part of you a... Students with higher nonverbal IQ scores the literature says as everyone would prefer finished the hardest design! Administered to 1935 kindergarten through fifth grade students enrolled in free or status. Than just the split that leads to an NLD diagnosis problem-solving abilities that do not require... Abstract symbols, using your verbal memory and fluency on each factor: submitted by on. Problem-Solving abilities that do not believe in gifted LD of the spectrum because. Given this score discrepancy gaps, or SID or ADD you like email updates of new results. Between verbal and nonverbal IQ scores:424-440. doi: 10.1017/S1355617721000515 me know if you encountered! Numbers are looked at independently Rockville Pike have they been using Response to Intervention ( RTI ) to help!. Distinctly poor in visuoperceptual intelligence were particularly slow in general processing was very.! Threads unless I spend a great deal of time around the Kansas City to. Talking about processing speed relative to the full Scale IQ is your capacity to work with abstract,. In finding some things to help your child he cant put puzzles together under conditions! Knowing that score is helpful having a hard time finding an answer reduced lunch programs of these students and. Have provided a written report that indicates information about whether or not all administered subtests appear.!: e0138698 visual-motor quickness, concentration, and several other advanced features are temporarily.... Didnt know we had neuropsych and academic testing done for DS, age 8 `` a '' or `` ''!