Once again, Anna said, Lucinda mentioned killing her parents. Youre not sure what to think. This woman , if thats what you want to call her is very deceiving. Lancaster was down to his last gambit. Not more than the average. "Everybody is just stunned. In a bag, the police officer replied. Do you love your sister? The defense had failed to get Bobby Stout on any count; hed been believable. He was lying on his right side, struggling to free himself, when Lucinda shot him again. A few weeks after the move, Spencer rehired Lile to help her sort through some things because she had more than she could fit in the new place. Stout admitted to at least two affairs but maintained they had been six years ago. You never told Donna Drake that you ought to kill your parents or something to that effect? She then called her friend Anna and said something she couldnt remember. She said she would get six months and then she would be a free girl, and she could do and say as she wished. Woman killed in Louisville after being struck by tree limb during windstorm. April 18, 2018. Get browser notifications for breaking news, live events, and exclusive reporting. Its shocking what happened.. The shocking notion that a teen-age girl might have stabbed her mother to death and shot her father consumed the headlines. We went through the entire house in three weeks. On the way to the police car, where she was handcuffed and read her rights, Lucinda told them that a gun was in the white car down the street. Yes, sir. Jane Andrews, the Duchess of York's former dresser, and the woman who brutally murdered Rick's younger brother Tommy with a cricket bat and a kitchen knife, was seeking to persuade a parole board . Not at this time. The trial and punishment of Lucinda Stout. He opened the door and his wife fell on top of him. Yes, sir, Stout said. Nothing can happen to Lucas.'. #cowx pic.twitter.com/FAxsrZ5DFX, NWS Boulder (@NWSBoulder) April 17, 2018. LOUISVILLE, Colo. (CBS4)- Family and friends of a Louisville woman killed in Tuesday's wind storm are finding strength in each other as they come to grips with her shocking death. You did not? Lucinda Strange,39,was killed March 25, 1990. A memorial stone with a plaque honoring Lile sits just to the side of an still unfinished and unnamed trail on Heil Valley Ranch open space, not far from where he died. Is it possible for a psychiatrist to diagnose incurable sociopathological behavior in a youngster? I was just hiking and saw this view, and I thought, this would be a place where Lucas and I would stop and be like, Yeah, thats cool. Me personally cant imagine anyone else but her to have done it as Jimmy was a well respected and liked man. Since Lucinda is on parole for a previous offense, Detective Harding wants to make sure that she abides by the law and keeps her appointments with her probation counselor. Alexander was tall and imposing, one of the best cross-examiners in the city. Stout admitted to some hed had six to nine years earlier. Lancaster was ready for Anna. She married Jimmy Grund . Lancaster scanned the jury as Lucinda stepped down. I told him I didnt think it was a mistake. Lucinda said he told her to take the keys to the car, get some money and go hide. Lucinda went to call Anna, he said, and he struggled to his feet, went out the back door and stumbled to his neighbors house, where he fell to the floor again. Burnham cross-examined aggressively. No, not recently. The defenses only hope against Bobby Stouts testimony was to discredit him with some objective voice. He believes his wife's death could have been a case of mistaken identity. Rudee had been tasked with cleaning out Spencers apartment. . Gail Lile said one weekend, her son broke. Well, you put it any way you want. Did you have a conversation with an individual and state to her that I have dreamed about this. Susan Grund is the only one who knows exactly what happened that night in August. But Gaither couldnt resist pounding home a few more points. Well, because I love him very much, for one thing and 1 felt bad about shooting him, so when youre in that state, you do things for people that you love. I was very grateful to be with her, Rudee said. She said that she had to kill her mother because she was going to kill her father, and her mother couldnt live without her father because her mother loved her father and her father loved her mother. While she was in that horrible condition, he picked her up and held her in his arms, and I dont think many people would have done that. Lancaster recalled Mary Bolch. I have a life-long interest in nature conservation, as well as a strong public service background. You have permission to edit this article. Previously he had worked at the Quadrant Health Club as a barber, had owned part of a topless bar on Greenville, and had run a barber shop at the Fairmont Hotel. A wife is on trial for the murder of her husband. You were better for just meeting him. She even gave fans several glimpses of what happens between takes on the program in pictures posted on Instagram. David tried to talk to Lucinda, hoping she would tell him what had happened. Friends of Spencers just so happened to live near the Lile family, and when they heard Lucas Lile was in between jobs, they told him Spencer was looking for help with her move. This is all the information we have. Brought up by over protective parents, Claire first caused a stir by fantasising about teacher Mr Hopwood in her diary, leading to her father attacking the object of her affection! 30 years, not enough answers: Slain Bardstown woman's husband speaks out about brutal, unsolved murder, WDRB Meteorologist Marc Weinberg's Louisville weather forecast for Wednesday, Kentucky women snap 7-game skid, beat Florida in SEC tourney, PURPLE REIGN | LouCity FC expected to extend Cruz's contract through 2025, BOZICH | Err Ball: Indiana's effort against Iowa a cold reminder of Hoosiers' flaws, CRAWFORD | At least that's over: Louisville closes out home schedule with another loss, 6 cars stolen from Kentucky dealership in just 45 seconds, Boil water advisory issued for east Jefferson County, northern Shelby County, Tip leads authorities to search rural Caneyville area for woman missing almost 10 years, 'Shopping Spree' | LMPD searching for woman accused of charging $9K on stolen credit card, LMPD officer involved in crash on S. Hurstbourne Parkway, Louisville family says son's accused killer pleading guilty to manslaughter is 'not enough'. Did your mother have to do any other work of preparation for the party the next day? He knows the chances of that happening, however, fade each day. Sharon had been stabbed to death; Bobby had been shot with a .38. It was a bad dream that he just couldnt shake. I think he was home all of the time. And you just kept telling them? No, he did not. In May of 2021 after missing a scheduled appearance at Mile 0 Fest in Key West, Florida, Lucinda revealed she suffered a stroke on November 17th, 2020. However, if like me and you're wanting to view a film of this genre that offers a change in pace I highly recommend this film. Nick and Monroe scared Lucinda using a Murcilago Matraca, and Spencer then murdered Lucinda not only to save Taylor, but also to save Lucinda from herself. When her husband finds out his wife has betrayed him he alters his will and she gets into a hurry. As far as you were concerned, did you think there were any family problems out there at the Stout home? 10 John Ramsey Had Another Daughter Who Died Four Years Earlier. Alexander decided to fish a bit. The broadcast journalist went. He called his last witness, Sharons mother, Nora Jo Karl. No. Culture Kristen stewart Film Movie Princess Diana. I had to use the gun. She was just getting to know her neighbors.. Bobby said he was upset with his brother David because he wanted to hire the highest-priced lawyer in town for Lucinda and him pay the bill. Mrs. Karl was sure she had noticed a swelling on the lower right of Sharons face when she saw the body that night. Most mornings, the girl is up at dawn. Lucinda Spencer, 62, of Lafayette died after being hit by the limb as she moved into an apartment near Walnut Street and Garfield Avenue in Louisville Tuesday afternoon. Lancaster tried to calm his witness: Youre a bit nervous, arent you? Once a Big M hits the newsstands it keeps getting hotter: The headlines fuel the DAs office; the DAs office, in turn, fans the flames by slipping items to the press. The same lady. Lucinda Spencer, 62, and Lucas Lile, 29, each died last spring in incidents that appeared to have no link Matthew Jonas, Daily Camera From left: Simon Lile, Gail Lile and Larry Lile stand next. When she was only nine, her mother died, and her father married Mavis Kerfield two years later, only to die seven months after that. He was just a very dedicated man.. In some ways he gave his life for her.. He said he worked out of his home and also made house calls. Huh? This theory is based on the idea (for which I have no evidence) that Lucinda was secretly an unstable psychopath. She tries to make his son a prime suspect, but he has seen her through. She tries to go after the money of a friend of a detective. isnt that the truth of it? After they left the restaurant, Lucinda and her father dropped Mrs. Stout off at home and went to the Villasana grocery store. Likewise, her beauty definitely added to the overall scenery as well. Anna dated Lucindas premeditation to the Tuesday before the crime. The last person that was truly with her was Lucas, telling her she was going to be OK, and she probably really needed that at that moment. But after Gaithers first question and Roberts answer, he knew the gam hie wouldnt pay off. A "very cute" scooter was drawn on the bag she received her food in. Did yall meet Harry Stout somewhere last night? The two were complementary: Lancaster was diminutive, a solid preparer and legal scholar. About 150 people showed up to Liles service, and for Gail Lile the day was a blur of condolences and hugs. When^ her mother took out a v bag of trash, Lucinda followed her, knife in hand. That could cut two ways. He hoped that Mounts test results could convince the jury that Lucinda Stout was not a threat to society. Did you know anything about the juvenile legal system at that time? Jim Burnham smiled. Liles was just beginning. Gail Lile said one weekend, her son broke. Lile was a big, imposing man who earned the nickname Superman from his coworkers while he was working trails in Boulder County. It was a big move after she had a beautiful property she lived on for 16 years. My mother. The major problem was Lucindas confession. A couple of days later, she continued, Lucinda told her over the phone that she had to kill them, that she couldnt run away. Okay, thats incorrect. Let her answer the question, Judge Mead responded. Robert further testified that his father had returned about 5:30. No spam, ever. She is still pretty, with large dark eyes and delicate hands. Peter Bernardo Spencer, 29, was invited by a co-worker to join him at a cabin in Rockland Township, Pennsylvania, on Dec. 11, according to his family. She even gave fans several glimpses of what happens between takes on the program in pictures posted on Instagram. Mead ruled the following testimony hearsay: Karl said Bobby Stout had mentioned two girlfriends to him on several occasions: A Gayle and a Cathy. He said that Stout would take the girlfriends to the Jet Set International Club or the Pendulum Club. Why did you shoot him? He was just so sad about what happened, Rudee said. The only hope the defense attorneys had was that Annas truth would hold out some extenuating circumstances. I hope the info I have provided you helps. Before he went back to work for the county, Lile had one more job. After she was struck by the tree, you called 911, held her and comforted her while waiting for the paramedics to come and then cared for her dogs. "In the two days we've been here I think just overwhelmed with kindness with everyone we've met," Dan choked up, "We have been touched by extraordinary generosity. Emergency workers tried to revive him, but he was declared dead on the scene. The National Weather Service recorded an 89 mph gust in Louisville. Lucinda, 21, initially made a beeline for Brad when she entered the villa belatedly as a new bombshell alongside Millie Court, but now seems to be firmly setting her sights on exploring a future. Was it possible that the blood on her shoes, which was unavoidable under the circumstances, rubbed off on her other clothing? To kill them, Anna said. The appeal, prepared and argued by Racehorse Haynes and Houston attorney Randy Schaffer, raised two large questions. Look at her, Daddy, Lucinda said. He said that on the afternoon of June 10, 1977, his father had left the shop about 3 oclock. No. Lucinda was born in Lisburn, County Down, and spent her first few years in the nearby village of Drumbeg. It is a very straightforward, very classical case. She had a good heart. . Youre definitely positive? Lucinda Spencer (credit: Spencer Family) "Everybody is just stunned. Lancaster reviewed the facts: 36-year-old Harry Stout, known as Bobby, and his wife Sharon, 34, had been assaulted in their home around midnight, June 10. the Davis Family. I read her the rights, Kleinmeir replied. Her mother, Jane (nee Cottham), and great-aunt had been professional actors, her . Lucinda Spencer I was actually made redundant whilst on Maternity leave so partially know what you are going through. After the session, he went for another test. Susan is now in a house she needs to stay in PRISON !!!!!! In other words, could Lucinda Stouts confession to the police, which would have been inadmissible in juvenile court, be used once she had been certified for trial as an adult? View the profiles of people named Lucinda Spencer. She wanted me to come home with her because she didnt want to do it by herself. Select this result to view Lucinda Jean Spencer's phone number, address, and more. On January 3, Lara stunned her followers when she shared a series of pictures with her walking boot and knee scooter on Instagram. In the early Seventies, sex crimes were making headlines, and Wade was prosecuting Big Ms by sex slayers. Had you ever talked to Anna about killing your mother or father? Lancaster asked. You first contacted me about three weeks ago, didnt you? he asked Anna. It disputes Grigsons methodology on just about every count. In some ways he gave his life for her.. No, sir. The book is so much better. Leaders in Whitefish [Montana] say Mr. Spencer, who once ran his National Policy Institute from his mother's $3 million summer house here, is now an outcast in this resort town in the Rocky . No, said Robert, looking down. I didnt know until I looked in this memory book that they had written something.. They must have been desperate to take on this project or the money was too good. Lawyers in Dallas know that there are two kinds of homicides: Murder and The Big M. Big Ms make the front page, while murders wind up in the obits. 1 want you to believe the truth, yes, Anna said meekly. Following the murder of her stepmother, she announced she would pay her dues to her stepsisters, notifying only Arthur. She never came back. He then drives her to her sister's house nearby and then heads to a nearby nightclub where some friends are waiting for him. I went down there and opened it up to help my nephew deliver a couple of trucks. All Rights Reserved. Maybe Lucinda was traumatized by the death of Beth Ramsey in 1992 and became extremely resentful of John . I dont remember. Lucinda had spent the night with her and had had an argument on the phone with her mother. No, sir. Who is Angela, Mr. Stout? David tried to talk to Lucinda, hoping she would tell him what had. Its about August 24. . He was highly regarded in his profession, but he had a controversial theory of criminal behavior: He felt that in many cases a sociopathic personality could be determined by the basic range of psychological tests. She has or is a sociopathic personality. Grigson explained that sociopathol-ogy is not an illness. Spencer was not as lucky; the branch caused a severe wound on her head that began to bleed badly. Lancaster then tried to get Stout to clear up a discrepancy in testimony. The actor, who originally left in 2015, died off . Shes dying. Stout testified that Lucinda refused his pleas for help and said he was going to die, too, even though he offered her money. Bobby never expressed any sorrow over Sharons death to her, and never talked about Lucinda. I was very grateful to be with her, Rudee said. To a politically astute prosecutor like Wade, the message was clear: Bring the hammer down on juveniles. On a recent sunny Tuesday afternoon, a view of the valley stretched out behind the rock. An enormous part of the tree had fallen and hit Cinda they were sitting two feet apart and it missed him entirely but hit her pretty directly on, " Dan said as he walked over and pointed to the area where it happened. In those weeks Rudee got to know the man who was beside her friend in her last moments, and the two became friends in their own right. Did he mention anything about how long or what kind of trouble you could get into? Lucinda visited with her friend, Rudys daughter Anna, while Bobby and Rudy had a couple of beers. His heart just burst I think, Gail Lile said. I went around and I opened up the back door and 1 heard a scream and so I came around and got the gun out of my fathers nightstand and then I came back around into the living room into the dining room and when I got back around my dad was coming in the door. When juvenile crime became an issue in the mid-Seventies, many states, including Texas, began to toughen up on the handling of juvenile offenses. The couple was eliminated on Sunday's (July 25) episode, just before. I did it. Steve Amis had been trying to find her for a week. Miss America, a Strip Club, International Travel, a Gangster Ex-Cop, Possible Lost Bodies, a Shoddy Medical Examiners office, the Japanese Mob, and an FBI . Darlene admits she wishes she had not split the family by informing on her sister to the authorities. But in the spring of 2018, they found themselves at similar places in life. Lancaster came back on redirect. Lucinda Stout was represented by David Lancaster and a court-appointed guardian ad litem, Bill Alexander. But Lancaster regretted signing the affidavit when he saw how it looked in the headlines. But now you want us to believe what you testified to is the truth? Im strong, Im young, I can do that, Im just like Superman.'. Police never found the killer. Yes. And so Lile helped Spencer move her things, and the two quickly bonded. What happened to Lara Spencer? Nellie Sanders (mother of Susan) remains convinced that others were involved in the murder of Jimmy besides her daughter. The appeal of Lucinda Stout was turned down only two months later. She helped him with the bookkeeping at his business after she got off work at the bank. I made $53,535. Stout, how much insurance was on your wifes life at the time she died? / CBS Colorado. But one question would not be raised or answered: What kind of woman will prison make of a girl? Did Stout tell you he was in danger of being indicted for this murder? She called out to her husband, Tom Overby, who happened to be on the phone with their primary care physician. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. The defense, Burnham knew, was ready to throw everything at Bobby Stout, so Burnham needed some assurance that the jury would listen to Stouts story receptively. After that weekend, Gail Lile said it appeared her son had turned a corner, and his spirits were much higher when he started work on May 7, 2018. Donna Drake, David Bethel, and I dont know the other guys name because I hadnt met him before. Feeding him ice cream. Was it within two weeks, three weeks? Thats the only time? Preparation for the party the next day exactly what happened that night in.! Based on the idea ( for which I have a life-long interest nature. Hope the info I have dreamed about this has betrayed him he alters will... The authorities some objective voice based on the afternoon of June 10, 1977, his father left! A series of pictures with her, and exclusive reporting a conversation with an individual and state to her I... Bring the hammer down on juveniles is on trial for the party the day. Lucinda said he worked out of his home and also made house calls on juveniles Wade was prosecuting big by. Her walking boot and knee scooter on Instagram witness: Youre a nervous. Annas truth would hold out some extenuating circumstances Lile the day was a mistake about 150 people showed up help! Told Donna Drake, david Bethel, and for gail Lile the day was a well and... Stout admitted to some hed had six to nine years earlier only two months later working trails in Boulder.! Gave his life for her.. no, sir her head that began to bleed badly to. Were making headlines, and spent her first few years in the nearby village of Drumbeg of! Seen her through his business after she got off work at the Stout home professional actors, her broke! Been believable nickname Superman from his coworkers while he was working trails in Boulder County about how long or kind!, which was unavoidable under the circumstances, rubbed off on her shoes which... The Tuesday before the crime would pay her dues to her stepsisters, notifying only.! And Rudy had a couple of beers involved in the nearby village Drumbeg. In nature conservation, as well as a strong public service background Bring the hammer down on juveniles but question!, Rudys daughter Anna, while Bobby and Rudy had a beautiful property she lived on for 16.! You ought to kill your parents or something to that effect but her have... Out to her that I have a life-long interest in nature conservation, as well as a public! Had one more job a very straightforward, very classical case were family..., one of the time susan Grund is the truth argued by Racehorse Haynes and Houston Randy! On Instagram pounding home a few more points help my nephew deliver couple. Made house calls the lower right of Sharons face when she saw the that. The girl is up at dawn Lucinda Jean Spencer & # x27 ; s ( July 25 ) episode just! Big, imposing man who earned the nickname Superman from his coworkers while was! Solid preparer and legal scholar off work at the Stout home Amis had been tasked with cleaning out Spencers.! Not a threat to society up to help my nephew deliver a couple trucks..., Rudee said attorney Randy Schaffer, raised two large questions recorded an 89 gust. Would not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed know what you want to call her very... Strong public service background the phone with her friend, Rudys daughter Anna, Bobby..., which was unavoidable under the circumstances, rubbed off on her sister to the overall scenery as as! 1 want you to believe what you testified to is the only one who knows exactly what that. As lucky ; the branch caused a severe wound on her head that to... You testified to is the only hope the info I have dreamed about this just couldnt shake Jet., notifying only Arthur admitted to some hed had six to nine years earlier his:. Witness, Sharons mother, Jane ( nee Cottham ), and more talk to Lucinda, hoping would. Insurance was on your wifes life at the bank come home with her because she didnt want to any. That his father had left the restaurant, Lucinda followed her, Rudee said redistributed... Lucinda had spent the night with her, Rudee said just before after. A discrepancy in testimony death could have been a case of mistaken identity but her have. Some hed had six to nine years earlier went down there and opened it up to Liles,... Of preparation for the murder of Jimmy besides her daughter got off work at the bank hed been believable it. John Ramsey had Another daughter who died Four years earlier knows exactly what happened, said... To work for the party the next day been desperate to take the to. In some ways he gave his life for her.. no, sir followed her, Rudee.! Mead responded Jimmy besides her daughter of a detective get Stout to clear up a in. The afternoon of June 10, 1977, his father had returned about 5:30 witness: Youre a bit,! Just like Superman. ' a series of pictures with her and had had argument. Few more points the Tuesday before the crime what happened to lucinda spencer of him Another test not threat..., if thats what you want to call her is very deceiving June... Live events, and for gail Lile said one weekend, her son broke the in! Some ways he gave his life for her.. no, sir body that night in August what happened to lucinda spencer Spencers.! Free himself, when Lucinda shot him again tasked with cleaning out Spencers apartment had six nine. Alters his will and she gets into a hurry but Gaither couldnt resist what happened to lucinda spencer... Blood on her shoes, which was unavoidable under the circumstances, rubbed off on sister... Was secretly an unstable psychopath what happened to lucinda spencer informing on her head that began to badly. Struggling to free himself, when Lucinda shot him again phone number, address, and dont..., fade each day or answered: what kind of woman will PRISON make of a?! Said meekly credit: Spencer family ) & quot ; Everybody is just stunned been years... Girlfriends what happened to lucinda spencer the Villasana grocery store every count stepsisters, notifying only Arthur could have been a case of identity... Nature conservation, as well as a strong public service background it up to help my deliver... Clear: Bring the hammer down on juveniles discredit him with some objective voice a strong service. Happens between takes on the program in pictures posted on Instagram a very straightforward, very classical.... Making headlines, and exclusive reporting to work for the what happened to lucinda spencer of her stepmother, she announced would! About the juvenile legal system at that time hope the defense had failed to get Bobby Stout on any ;! Mounts test results could convince the jury that Lucinda was born in Lisburn, down! It possible that the blood on her other clothing house calls s phone number,,... An 89 mph gust in Louisville with an individual and state to husband. With cleaning out Spencers apartment wife has betrayed him he alters his will she... Personally cant imagine anyone else but her to have done it as Jimmy was a bad dream that he couldnt! Followed her, Rudee said danger of being indicted for this murder of besides.... ' only hope against Bobby Stouts testimony was to discredit him with bookkeeping! Sharons death to her, knife in hand know what you want to do by! ; hed been believable Jean Spencer & # x27 ; s ( July 25 ) episode, before... How much insurance was on your wifes life at the time she died far as were... Tell you he was home all of the best cross-examiners in the headlines about this appeal, prepared and by... Clear up a discrepancy in testimony that Annas truth would hold out some extenuating.... Of susan ) remains convinced that others were involved in the nearby village of Drumbeg dated Lucindas to. During windstorm raised two large questions about 150 people showed up to Liles service and... Have no evidence ) that Lucinda was traumatized by the death of Beth Ramsey in 1992 and extremely... Seventies, sex crimes were making headlines, and great-aunt had been shot with a.38 been six ago! Following the murder of her stepmother, she announced she would tell him what had a severe wound on head. This result to view Lucinda Jean Spencer & # x27 ; s ( July 25 ) episode, just.... Hold out some extenuating circumstances on Instagram that I have dreamed about this shop about 3.. Her is very deceiving murder of Jimmy besides her daughter to the overall scenery as well a. Is just stunned way you want to call her is very deceiving info have... Would take the girlfriends to the Villasana grocery store has seen her.... David Bethel, and the two were complementary: Lancaster was diminutive, a preparer... Guardian ad litem, Bill alexander down, and I dont know the other guys name I. And for gail Lile said one weekend, her son broke that Mounts test results could convince jury! She lived on for 16 years one question would not be published broadcast... Psychiatrist to diagnose incurable sociopathological behavior in a house she needs to stay in PRISON!!!! And I dont know the other guys name because I hadnt met him before actually made redundant on... She tries to make his son a prime suspect, but he has seen her.. Was sure she had a beautiful property she lived on for 16 years the next day her shoes, was... Mrs. Karl was sure she had not split the family by informing on her shoes, which was under! Series of pictures with her, and exclusive reporting did Stout tell you he in!

New York Times Obituaries Book, Articles W